≡ Menu

August 2009

Ice Cream

This comparison is a bit different than all the others because Costco only sells one brand of ice cream: Kirkland Signature. Of course, you can pick up a box of Haagen-Dazs bars or occasionally a tub of gelato. However, for straightforward ice cream, I’ve never seen anything other than the house brand, which really is quite good.

costco-ice-creampiazzas-ice-cream

So, Costco sells 2 x 1/2 gallon tubs of Kirkland Signature Super Premium Vanilla Ice Cream for $6.99. I spotted a coupon for Breyers Ice Cream from Piazza’s Fine Foods. $2.99 gets you a 48 oz. carton of delicious, all natural ice cream. Since 48 ounces is 0.375 gallons, the cost per gallon is $7.97, or about a dollar more than the price at Costco. Of course, the big difference is that I can pick a flavor other than vanilla

Cetaphil Moisturizing Lotion: Costco v. Target

If I wasn’t paying close attention, I would have completely missed this one. At first glance, I thought that Target sold an individual pack of Cetaphil while Costco sold a twin pack.

costco-cetaphiltarget-cetaphil

However, upon closer inspection, I discovered that the Target was selling a 16 oz. bottle, while Costco was selling 2 x 20 oz. bottles. Anyways, Target sells Cetaphil Moisturizing Lotion for $0.559 per ounce while Costco sells it for $0.388 per ounce. If Costco sold a 16 oz. bottle at $0.388 per ounce, the total would be $6.21, quite a bit less than the $8.94 Target is charging.

Bona Hardwood Floor Cleaner at Lowe’s

I already know that Costco has the best price on Bona Hardwood Floor Cleaner. Who can beat $11.99 for a 1.25 gallon refill container and a 32 oz. spray bottle?

lowes-bona-hardwood-floor-cleaner

Lowe’s was selling a 128 oz. container of Bona Hardwood Floor Cleaner for $15.98, or $0.125 per ounce. Lowe’s price is half way between the $.0236 per ounce price at OSH and the $0.062 per ounce price at Costco.

AA Batteries

Lowe’s sells a 16 pack of Duracell AA batteries for $9.97.

lowes-aa-batteries

Costco sells the same 16 pack for $8.49. The Target 16 pack costs $10.39.

Allergan Refresh Plus

Previously, I had compared the price of Allergan Refresh Plus at Target and Costco.

walmart-refresh-plus

Wal-Mart sells a 30 single-use containers for $6.98 (or $0.233 per container) or 70 single-use containers for $13.94 (or $0.199 per container). Recall that Target sold the same 30-count box for $6.99, or one penny more than Wal-Mart. As usual, Costco sold Allergan Refresh Plus for lowest per unit price—$0.184 per single-use container.

Brita Filters at Wal-Mart

wal-mart-brita

Comparison shopping within a store is pretty easy with a calculator in hand. However, unless you store all your prices in a spreadsheet, this task can be challenging because quantities for even standard goods may differ.

Case in point: Brita water filters. Costco sells a 10 pack, Target sells a 6 pack, and Wal-Mart sells a 4 pack. Wal-Mart sells a 4 pack of Brita filters for $19.44, or $4.86 per filter. The best price from my last price check was $4.199 per filter from Costco. However, Wal-Mart did edge out Target be a few cents per filter (i.e., $4.86 v. $4.948). However, I spotted a 5-pack of Brita Water Filters at walmart.com selling for $39.98, or $7.996 per filter! The lesson here is to not assume that the in-store and online prices are the same, or that online prices much be cheaper than within a bricks and mortar store.

Mini-Wheats at Wal-Mart

Last month, I compared the price of Frosted Mini-Wheats at Costco and Safeway.

walmart-mini-wheats

This past weekend, I stopped by Wal-Mart to shop around. Wal-Mart sells an 18 oz. box of Kellogg’s Frosted Mini-Wheats for $2.33, or $0.129 per ounce. Costco is still the store to beat, but you have to buy a 70 oz. box. For 70 ounces, the Wal-Mart price will be $9.06, compared to $8.49 at Costco. So, I can save $13.71 a year if I can finish two 70 oz. boxes a month.

Shout Gel

A few weeks ago, OSH was selling an 8.7 oz. bottle of Shout Gel for $4.99. So, was this a “great value” as the sign proclaimed?

osh-shout-geltarget-shout-gel

Target, which used to carry Shout Gel, did not have the product on its shelves. Instead, it stocked an 8.7 oz. bottle of Shout Advanced Gel for $2.64. Between the two, Target offered a greater value.

Bona Hardwood Floor Cleaner

This exercise in tracking the cost of various products that I usually purchase has really focused my attention on consumer prices. I know that gas prices change daily, but what about the price of other consumer goods?

Since the last post on Bona Hardwood Floor Cleaner, I noticed that the Costco had changed its price. Since the schools only teach about inflation (and not deflation), you may think that prices will only go up absent a sale or rebate. But, there I was looking at the sign and sure enough, Costco now sells Bona Hardwood Floor Cleaner for $11.99 instead of $12.69. No sale. No instant rebate. Just a straightforward price cut. Wow!

costco-bona

S&W Corn

Summer is a great time for corn. Every week, I buy 10 ears of the freshest corn for $6.00 from the Mountain View Farmers Market. The yellow corn is the sweetest, but the white and the bi-color corn are delicious as well. Unfortunately, during the week, I have to turn to the canned corn stored in the pantry. Not as fresh and sweet as the corn from the Farmers Market, but it’s corn.

mutant-corn

Even the mutant corn is sweet. However, the extra appendage was worthless.

piazza-corn

Piazza’s sells a 15.25 oz of S&W Whole Kernel Corn for $1.69.

costco-corn

Costco sells 12×15.25 oz cans of S&W Whole Kernel Corn for $9.39, or $0.783 per can, which is less than half the price at Piazza’s. And, those 12 cans have quite a shelf life, so buying a 12 pack makes sense if you enjoy corn. I really wish Costco will sell cream style corn. That goes well with everything.